8 alternatives ranked by how much of Black XS’s actual note structure they share — not by opinion. The closest is Al Basel by Swiss Arabian at 90%.
| # | Fragrance | House | Year | Note match | Shared notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Al Basel | Swiss Arabian | 2014 | 90% | Black Amber, Black Cardamom, Brazilian Rosewood, Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli, Praline, Sage |
| 2 | Smart Black | Fragrance World | 2018 | 46% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli, Praline, Sage, Tolu Balsam |
| 3 | Shaghaf Men | Swiss Arabian | — | 46% | Black Amber, Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli, Praline, Sage, Tolu Balsam |
| 4 | Man Gold | Zara | — | 38% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Praline |
| 5 | Gold | Zara | — | 33% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli |
| 6 | Classy Chic Girl | Fragrance World | 2020 | 29% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli, Praline |
| 7 | Diva Glamorous Girl | Fragrance World | 2022 | 28% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli, Praline |
| 8 | Black Onyx | Armaf | — | 28% | Cinnamon, Lemon, Patchouli |
Each candidate is scored on three things: how many notes it shares with the original (weighted so rare materials count for more than common ones like musk), how closely the base and heart match — the part that determines the drydown — and how similar the overall accord profile is. Nothing here is based on marketing claims or on anyone’s opinion, and nothing has been smelled side by side. It is a structural comparison of what these fragrances are made of, which is a strong guide but not a guarantee of how they wear.
Compare them in the interactive atlas →